Disliked Beauty Products

1

I'm not one for writing bad reviews. If I don't like a product I just don't mention it as I find negative reviews boring to write. However there should be more of a balance and sometimes it is good to be warned about a product. So here is a collection of products I really don't rate! 

I feel I should point out that I have tried to select products that aren't just 'out of date' but some are a result of that and I feel shouldn't be as bad as they are. I hope that makes sense! An example of what I mean is the ELF Cream Liner below. 

2

Jelly Pong Pong Jelly Flush Cheek Stain  - £12.00 
I have always been on the fence when it comes Jelly Pong Pongs products -  I love their super cute packaging and different ideas for products but I think most lack in quality and practicality. The practicality of the cheek stain is the main issue here, it is just so messy! As you can see from the bottom of the product it has leaked, however it also leaks outside of the packaging with the lid screwed on! Also when holding this to apply it to the cheeks the mess from the packaging gets on your hands... it's just not good. That aside the cheek stain itself isn't that great either, offering very little pigment that does need topping up during the day, though this isn't a product you would want anywhere near your handbag! 

E.L.F Cream Eyeliner - £3.75 
This is a product I have mentioned quite a few times on my blog for being a nice pigmented creamy eyeliner. However as you can see the product has dramatically shrank in size and has gone hard. This can only be put down to how long I have had it, but I am not one for listening to the PAO symbols on beauty products as I have had some products for the longest time and they are still going strong. But sadly this has been one that does have a short shelf life. 

3

Sleek Truly Mattely Deeply Lip Gloss in Jazz (from Shangri-La Collection) - £4.99 
When I received this through the post when the Sleek Shangri-La collection came out I was eager to try it as the shade was so bold and was intrigued by the sound of a matte lip gloss. But sadly this couldn't have failed more as a product if it tried! The packaging did state to apply the 'lip gloss' over well moisturised lips, which is what I did, but as soon as the lip gloss 'set' I was left with such an odd dry feeling to my lips that was actually uncomfortable to keep on. I mean my lips felt as dry as a desert. I of course didn't give up and applied a lip balm over the top in hope it would hydrate the lip gloss a bit but that didn't seem to help at all. Just an awful product that just isn't a lip gloss. The only thing I was impressed by was the amazing pigmentation to it. 

Stila Oil-free Tinted Moisturizer - Purchase from Poundland
With this product I'm not sure whether to blame Stila, Poundland or the product itself, but I thought I would include it anyway. I purchased this in Poundland quite some time ago and then quite soon after the Stila products being sold in Poundland were featured in a Channel 4 program highlighting that the stock could well be upto 4 years old. Now I had purchased it and been happy with the product and knowing a product could be so old but still sealed didn't really bother me - I prefer to go by the consistency and smell of a product to decided if it is out of date or not. However within two months of using this the texture became quite thick and waxy feeling, almost as if the SPF in the product was separating and I was getting more SPF than tinted moisturiser. Safe to say this is now in the bin, but for only a £1 I really didn't lose much.

 Bourjois Sweet Kiss Lipstick - £7.99 
I picked this up in Tesco due to realising I had never tried a Bourjois lipstick before. I like the look of the packaging and thought the lipstick was a nice everyday shade. But sadly we just didn't get on... I found the texture to be quite waxy, meaning the application dragged, it didn't feel the best on the lips and I felt it enhanced the lines in my lips. The only plus side to the texture was that it did have good staying power but as I am use to reapplying lip products this wasn't something I needed over the other three things. I do love a lot of other Bourjois products but know I won't be trying another lipstick from them due to there being other brands such as Rimmel and Revlon that offer amazing lip products

Hope you enjoyed this more 
negative type of post! 

Fee xo.  

SHARE:

Comments (33)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I like seeing honest negative reviews - they're helpful!
xx
1 reply · active 629 weeks ago
I'm surprised about that sleek lipgloss, I've only ever heard great things about sleek products. Great post! xxx
1 reply · active 629 weeks ago
I agree I prefer writing about the products I like but it's very helpful to see what you didn't like to know what to avoid:)
ooh I have a similar post scheduled for later in the week :)

this was a good post to read. It's always good to get a view on the good and the bad!

cllrs.blogspot.com
I think that this kind of reviews, if they're not too bad, are a good thing. Sometimes I buy products because I read good feedback on blogs and website, so if I read bad reviews (with the right motivations) I often avoid to buy them, most of all if they're expensive. www.webelieveinstyle.net
Thank you, it's always good to know what products not to purchase!
http://lexiaa2202.blogspot.com/

x
I found that Stila tinted moisturizer pretty bad too. I ended up buying 3 of them despite not knowing what it'd be like. Always getting sucked into a poundland bargain! I wanted to mix it with other products but the consistency is so horrible and it's about 4 shades too dark for me.
May Flowers's avatar

May Flowers · 629 weeks ago

Always good to read what you shouldn't buy just as much as what you should.
Great reviews doll! http://mayflowersblog.blogspot.co.uk/
DON'T CHUCK THE EYELINER!

I had exactly the same problem with mine but you can bring it back to life by putting a thin coat of vasaline over it, leave it over night and in the morning it should have the moisture back in it :)
1 reply · active 629 weeks ago
seems like you got a tiny bit confused... no review for the stila tinted moisuriser and no photo of the bourjois lipstick?! howevs i really liked this post, you're great at good and bad cheaper makeup and yours is my favourite beauty blog by a million miles! thanks for updating so regularly xx
1 reply · active 629 weeks ago
Not sure what blog post you're seeing, @rosygirl but I'm seeing both a pic of the bourjois lipstick and a review for the stila product :)

Thanks for this post, I think these are just as important as posts about what we like :D
Great post! It's nice seeing honest opinions on products! :)
http://those-material-things.blogspot.co.uk/
Not every product can be raved about; it's good to have a balance of positive and negative reviews - makes for interesting reading :). Great post!

Tara xox
I've got the ELF gel eyeliner and mine did the same, but only after a few weeks, went really hard so it became difficult to work with. I havent used it for a long time now so I'm going to look at it to see if mine has shrunk too! That jelly pong pong cheek stain looks really sticky too! I have one of their lipglosses and although a gorgeous flavour/scent, its pretty gooey on the lips. x
Hayley Loves's avatar

Hayley Loves · 629 weeks ago

I like reading these kind of posts! I put my disappointing products up today too :)
lastyearsheroxo.blogspot.co.uk xxx
In my opinion, bad reviews are sort of necessary when writing a beauty blog. I mean, there is something to be said for staying positive and using your blog to let the world know about good products, but there is also something to be said for not letting your audience waste money on crappy products.

I recently was very unsatisfied with a Clinque moisturizer, and at first I thought maybe I just wouldn't mention it at all. However, once I started thinking about it, I really didn't want anyone who reads my blog to buy the same product and be as disappointed as I was. The same with people who are searching for reviews for the product.

I mean, I think you did a good job giving your honest opinion and leaving it at that. It's once the reviewer just starts getting plain mean that things get out of hand. You know?
Well, my ELF eyeliner looked like this when I bought it! It applied okay (I'm not a massive fan of eyeliner, why I bothered I'm not sure!) but I just thought the shrunken look was normal, my bad!

xo
I actually really appreciate these posts since it helps me decide what products not to buy. I definitely wont complain about a post that saves me money!!
www.laurenzie.com
Think of it as being honest, not negative. It's always good to hear both sides
www.underthecherryrainbow.blogspot.co.uk
I love the bourjois sweet kiss lipstick and i didnt found it bad anyways
I totally agree with the ELF liners. They are brilliant and so cheap but they dry up so quick. I have a maybelline one that I have had for about a year longer than the ELF one and although it is a bit dry now aswell, at least you can still use it. Mine is like a brick now! x

Post a new comment

Comments by

Blogger Template Created by pipdig